Maybelline New York Expert Tools, Eyelash Curler Refills

I liked them

I have been looking for years for these refills. This has been my favorite lash curler since I was 12, but I could never find replacement refills. I am so happy to have found these I will be buying backups for sure!!

Update: I had ordered several extra packages before the first one I had problems with. I've now had the same issue with two more packages. I am officially removing this from my Subscribe and Save, and looking for a new eyelash curler!I've been ordering these through Amazon for years now, with no real problems. Yes, sometimes an end pops out, but nothing I can't easily fix and move on with getting ready for work. However, the package I just opened (identical to every previous package) is visibly thicker, with considerably smaller indentations on the bottom edge, than any others. Unfortunately, they simply will NOT stay in the curler at all. They are too thick for the channel, and won't go far enough down because the indentations are not there to fit around the handle ends. Fortunately, I had another package and was able to replace them and continue getting ready for work, but I'm very disappointed in this package and no longer trust that what I buy is going to work!

Just what I needed. No complaints!

I have been on the hunt for refills to fit my Cover Girl eyelash curler that I've had since the 80's and these fit! They're a teensy bit too short but it doesn't matter, they stay in and work fine. I'm not sure why there are so many one star reviews. I'm wondering if people are curling their eyelashes after they apply mascara which you are not supposed to do! That can break your eyelashes!

I have a drug store curler (brand unknown) and I thought this refill didn't fit, so I requested & rec'd a refund. But after a couple of weeks, I tried to install the refill once more before throwing it away. I pressed harder, and it fits perfectly. The value of quality are perfect! I shouldn't have gotten the refund and would like to pay again for the product now that I know it wasn't the wrong size. Amazon, what shall I doooooo?

Not sure why some are saying that these are awful. I think they are perfect. I used to use the old white ones made out of rubber - they always ended up with a groove from use and quite a lot of my lashes were literally cut off. These are made out of silicone, which does not wear down into a groove. And I believe that they curl better. Very happy that Maybelline changed their product and made it so much better.

Perfect size for Maybelline or Cover Girl eyelash curler. I like the blacks pads because if they pop out and fall on the floor or counter, they are much easier to find than the white ones that comes with the actual eyelash curler. They were reasonably priced.